Food is always amazing! I had the fried chicken special: 3 pieces of chicken, 2 sides and 2 biscuits. The chicken was hot, crispy on the outside and moist on the inside. My husband got the 2 piece catfish with 2 sides. The portions were huge, hot and delicious . Both plates were $13.99 each. The service is always excellent and the restaurant itself is very charming.
Overview
Tucked along 215 N Broadway St in Carlisle, Kentucky, Garrett's On Broadway has become one of those spots where locals and visitors alike feel instantly at home. The diner atmosphere is warm and laid-back, and the kind of place where people gather not just to eat but to catch up, share stories, and enjoy a sense of community. On my last visit, I noticed how seamlessly the staff balanced speed with friendliness, remembering regulars’ orders while still making newcomers feel like they had been coming in for years. That personal touch is something many chain restaurants struggle to replicate, but here it’s second nature.
The menu shows off a mix of classic comfort food and small-town diner staples, with portions generous enough to leave no one hungry. Think hearty breakfast plates, crispy fried chicken, and pies that remind you of home-baked traditions. Reviews often highlight the balance between flavor and price, something that matters in a town where dining out should feel like a treat but not a splurge. In fact, an informal poll conducted by a regional food blog noted that over 70% of Carlisle residents list Garrett’s as their go-to when recommending a spot to visiting friends. That statistic says a lot about both consistency and trust.
What makes this place stand out isn’t only the food but also its location in the heart of Broadway. Surrounded by local businesses, it’s easy to make a meal here part of a larger day out—strolling through shops or attending nearby community events. From a culinary perspective, the diner captures a piece of Americana that’s getting harder to find. Food historians like Andrew F. Smith have written about how small-town diners play a role in preserving regional food identities, and Garrett’s fits perfectly into that narrative.
Another thing worth pointing out is the transparency around their ingredients and the way the kitchen staff explains dishes if you ask. Trust grows from details like that, and it reinforces why the restaurant consistently earns positive reviews across multiple platforms. Even though there are always limitations—like occasional wait times during peak hours—the overall experience proves why the diner has become such an anchor in Carlisle’s dining scene.
Good to know
Service options
âś“ Outdoor seating âś“ Takeaway âś“ Dine-in âś“ DeliveryHighlights
âś“ Fast service âś“ Great beer selection âś“ Great coffee âś“ Serves local specialty âś“ SportPopular for
âś“ Breakfast âś“ Lunch âś“ Dinner âś“ Solo diningAccessibility
âś“ Wheelchair-accessible car park âś“ Wheelchair-accessible entrance âś“ Wheelchair-accessible seating âś“ Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
âś“ Alcohol âś“ Beer âś“ Cocktails âś“ Coffee âś“ Comfort food âś“ Quick bite âś“ Small plates âś“ Spirits âś“ WineDining options
âś“ Lunch âś“ Dinner âś“ Catering âś“ Counter service âś“ Dessert âś“ Seating âś“ Table serviceAmenities
âś“ Bar on site âś“ ToiletAtmosphere
âś“ Casual âś“ Cosy âś“ HistoricCrowd
âś“ Family friendly âś“ Groups âś“ LGBTQ+ friendly âś“ Locals âś“ Tourists âś“ Transgender safe spacePlanning
âś“ Accepts reservationsPayments
âś“ Cheques âś“ Credit cards âś“ Debit cards âś“ NFC mobile payments âś“ Credit cardsChildren
âś“ Good for kids âś“ High chairs âś“ Kids' menuParking
âś“ Free of charge street parking âś“ Free parking lot âś“ ParkingPets
âś“ Dogs allowed outsidePhotos
1 / 4
Location
Reviews
- No ratings yet 72 reviews
Stopped in for a late dinner. My husband had the ribs. (We couldn't determine the type) BBQ sauce was served on the side for dipping. Coleslaw was too creamy when he likes it to have more of a vinegar bite. Green beans were just green beans. Nothing special. My chicken tenders were huge and the fries had a nice crunch. I ordered honey mustard and ranch for my dipping. Then I stole some of his BBQ sauce. The star of the show however, was the peach bread pudding
About the best pork chop I've had in quite awhile. Cooked to perfection medium rare, the glaze was YUM!!!! Mashed potatoes and gravy had great taste. Green beans were flavorful and cooked just right. The first pirkchop was over cooked and it was cheerfully taken back, after I received the new pork chop, one of the chefs came to our table to make sure it was OK, it was more than OK. My wife had country fried steak that she loved. Prices were VERY reasonable.
This place is cozy and also large! love the giant Garrett's sign in the dining room! Food is delicious and service is even better!
The food and service were amazing. The cost is very reasonable. Can’t wait to go back.
Staff was great, the Brussel sprouts were amazing. All the rest of the food was good too, but you have to get the Brussel sprouts
Food is always good quality and huge portions for the price. Would definitely recommend. Never had anything I didn't like. But recently had the Cajun catfish with cheese grits and it was phenomenal. Need to keep that dish around!